"Who do you say that I am?"
by Rev. Alexandra Robinson on August 23, 2023
Reading: Matthew 16:13-20
This is the question that Jesus poses to Peter in our weekly word, and our response is just as relevant today as it was those many years ago. My guess is that if we are honest with ourselves, and who we truly believe Jesus is in our lives, our answers would vary to this question. Some might immediately reply “My Lord and Savior!” Some might thoughtfully reflect upon what it means that Jesus was a “Suffering Messiah.” Others might share personal testimony of Jesus as “Their Rock.” Some might wonder if Jesus was different from the prophets before him. Others might question how Jesus is the Son of God. And some might share their doubts if Jesus’ presence as proclaimed in the gospels is reality or a literary construct.
At least, this is what many people have shared with me about their beliefs in Jesus’ identity.
And unfortunately, some of those folks have been told that their answer is not right, not doctrinal, not theologically accurate, are told their answers are not good enough to be part of the church. But I want to tell you that wherever you are in this answer, Jesus will meet you right there.
Just listen to how Jesus responds to the disciples who have been learning from him, journeying with him, and watching him perform miracles. Despite all they have experienced first hand of Jesus’ presence, they are still trying to figure out who Jesus is. Their answers to his question of identity vary from being a resurrection of Jesus’ cousin to another prophet of Israel. If the disciples who are witnesses to Jesus’ ministry do not understand it fully, it is not relatable that our answers vary too?
Peter’s response that Jesus is “The Messiah, the Son of the Living God,” is the one on which Jesus shares the church must be built. Why? Because it is a living witness. The church is designed to be a living response, so that nothing of death can prevail against it. For the Messiah, is the Son of the Living God.
So what might this mean for us as the church, if the Son of the Living God is the answer to Jesus identity? Perhaps it means that the church is the living witness, not in our doctrinal responses or ensuring that we have the “right” answers theologically, but that we have actions in life matching Jesus’ presence. Perhaps as the church we must spend less time convincing people to have the right answers, and more time engaging in life giving behaviors as Jesus’ disciples.
This week, be a brave disciple in your living witness.
October 08, 2025
October 01, 2025
September 24, 2025